Happy Birthday, Burgess Meredith!
Posted by Ivan G. Shreve, Jr. on Nov 16th 2021
Two iconic roles immediately come to mind when discussing the career of the actor born Oliver Burgess Meredith on this date in 1907. One is his deliciously over-the-top portrayal of The Penguin on TV's Batman (1966-68), a memorable foe amongst the Caped Crusader's gallery of villains. The other is cantankerous corner man Mickey Goldmill from the Rocky movie franchise; the man affectionately known to his friends as "Buzz" was nominated for a Best Supporting Actor Oscar in the inaugural 1976 feature and reprised the role in three of the sequels. (His character dies in Rocky III [1982] but appears in a flashback in Rocky V [1990].) Meredith was considered one of the finest character actors in the business, whose six decades of performances were succinctly summed up by New York Times critic Mel Gussow as "a richly varied career in which he played many of the more demanding roles in classical and contemporary theater."
Burgess Meredith's work in radio, however, often gets
overlooked. (His Wikipedia entry mentions contributions in narration and
voice-overs...but skimps a little on radio.) Although he was already making a name for himself as a
stage presence at the same time he stood before a microphone, Meredith had a
true fondness for the aural medium. One of his finest acting showcases was on an April 11,
1937 broadcast of The Columbia Workshop in a production of Archibald MacLeish's "The Fall
of the City." Burgess played a pacifist in this presentation that also
featured Orson Welles and Edgar Stehli, and according to a 1938 Radio Stars interview "Buzz" offered his services to the
Columbia Broadcasting System gratis "Because I believe in it!" (CBS turned down
Meredith's magnanimous gesture and insisted on paying him the union-mandated amount of
$18.50.)
Burgess Meredith was a Cleveland, Ohio native, born to a
Canadian-born physician and a mother who was the daughter of a Methodist
revivalist. He lived in nearby Lakewood for a time, attending Madison
Elementary School, where his performing ambition was stoked by his
participation in school plays and as a boy soprano in the choir. Meredith
would eventually participate in a nationwide audition held by the Paulist
Choristers Boy Choir of New York. Burgess was selected as one of the winning
finalists...but his uncle and sister intervened and after another successful
audition he joined the choir at the Protestant Cathedral of St. John the
Divine. In his sub-teens, Buzz sang with the St. John Choir in NYC in exchange
for schooling, board, and lodging.
Burgess Meredith would graduate from the preparatory Hoosac
School in 1926 and then attended Amherst College (he failed trigonometry and
dropped out without graduating). With money always in short supply, Meredith
embarked on several employment excursions that included newspaper reporting
(for The Stamford Advocate), department store clerking, selling
vacuum cleaners and later roofing materials, and seamanship (he made two trips
to South America on a freighter). Burgess was tossed into the brig when he quit
this last job and passed the time by reciting lines from anything that came to
mind. This inspired him to join the prestigious Eva Le Gallienne Civic
Repertory Theatre in NYC in 1929.
Burgess Meredith developed an affinity for the footlights and
made a name for himself in the likes of Romeo and Juliet (1930), The Green Cockatoo (1930), Siegfried (1930), People On the Hill (1931), and Lillom (1932). Meredith scored considerable success in a
production of Alice in Wonderland (1932), following that with Little Ol' Boy (1933), She Loves Me Not (1933), The Barretts of Wimpole Street (1935), and Flowers of the Forest (1935). It was his performance as "Mio Romagna" in Maxwell
Anderson's Winterset (1935) that earned Buzz much critical acclaim (you
thought I was going to say "critical buzz," didn't you?). When the play reached the silver screen the following year, Burgess reprised the role in what would be his first credited motion
picture appearance. In years to follow, Meredith never completely abandoned
the stage—he appeared in such productions as The Playboy of the Western World (1946), The Fourposter (1951), The Teahouse of the August Moon (1953), The Remarkable Mr. Pennypacker (1953), and Major Barbara (1956). Burgess also directed several plays, notably
1960s A Thurber Carnival...which won him a special Tony Award (shared with
author-collaborator James Thurber).
Like many working thespians during the Depression era,
Burgess Meredith sought to supplement his income with radio work. The actor got
a break by landing the titular lead in Red Adams, one of the first daytime dramas created by Elaine
Carrington (later responsible for When a Girl Marries and Rosemary). Premiering over NBC Blue on October 2, 1932, Red Adams got a new sponsor in Beech-Nut Gum in September of
1933...and a new title in Red Davis (Beech-Nut insisted on the change because "Adams" was a gum competitor). The long-running soap opera would eventually
be known as Pepper Young's Family, lasting until January 16, 1959 (with a brief revival in
1964). Meredith left the program in 1934, replaced by Curtis Arnall.
Burgess Meredith later emceed The Pursuit of Happiness on CBS Radio from October 22, 1939 to May 5, 1940 - a program memorably described by Max Wylie as "a flag-waving
show" that "had the good sense not only to admit this at the
beginning but to insist upon it throughout the run of the series." One of the first directorial assignments for "radio's
poet laureate," Norman Corwin, Happiness allowed Meredith to preside over a half-hour collage of
dramatic skits and musical performances. Meredith later hosted The Free Company on the same network - a documentary drama that was described by old-time radio historian John Dunning as "an attempt by 14 major
American writers to counter what was seen as a tide of foreign propaganda
infiltrating the American press and radio." It had only a brief run in 1941 thanks to William Randolph Hearst,
who used his formidable newspaper empire to publish constant criticism of the program and bring about its cancellation. (Hearst's particular target was Free Company contributor/obedient servant Orson Welles, who was at
that moment lacerating the publisher in his immortal film Citizen Kane [1941].)
In the 1950s, Burgess Meredith served as host of ABC
Radio's American Music Hall, a Sunday evening variety
program produced by Paul Whiteman. Other programs on Burgess' radio resume
include Arch Oboler's Plays, Best Plays, Campbell
Playhouse, The Cavalcade of America, Command
Performance, The Fleischmann's Yeast Hour, Forecast, The
Gulf Screen Guild Theatre, Hallmark Playhouse, The
Harold Lloyd Comedy Theatre, Inner Sanctum Mysteries, The
Kate Smith Hour, Lincoln Highway, The Lux
Radio Theatre, Maxwell House Coffee Time, The
Radio Hall of Fame, The Radio Reader's Digest, The
Raleigh Room, Stagestruck, Studio One, The
Texaco Star Theatre, The Theatre Guild on the Air, This
is My Best, and We the People (Meredith
occasionally guest hosted).
Many of the programs listed above allowed Burgess Meredith to
promote his movie career. For example, the September 08, 1941 broadcast of The Lux Radio Theatre was a production of "Tom, Dick, and Harry"
with Burgess, Ginger Rogers, George Murphy, and Alan Marshal reprising their roles from the 1941 RKO comedy. Meredith's acting
career went into limbo in 1942 when he enlisted in the United States Army Air
Forces, where he achieved the rank of captain. His WW2 experience served him
well when he played war correspondent Ernie Pyle in the 1945 film The Story of G.I. Joe, as well as narrating the war drama A Walk in the Sun (1945). One of Burgess' best remembered feature films
was Of Mice and Men (1939); the actor reprised his role as
"George" on both The Theatre Guild on the Air (05/08/49) and Best Plays (05/08/53)...though his co-star from that film, Lon
Chaney, Jr., did not join him.
In 1949, Burgess Meredith directed the first of two feature
films he would helm during his career, The Man on the Eiffel Tower (he
also acted in the movie). (His second was The Yin and the Yang of Mr.
Go, in 1970.) His work in films started to slow when his liberal politics
ran afoul of the House Committee on Un-American Activities (and he found
himself on the blacklist), so Meredith compensated with radio and stage work.
He'd work again in Joe Butterfly (1957), but if anyone should
claim credit for Burgess' return to motion pictures it's director Otto
Preminger, who used the actor in Advise and Consent (1962), The
Cardinal (1963), In Harm's Way (1965), Hurry
Sundown (1967), Skidoo (1968), and Such Good
Friends (1971).
Burgess Meredith soon became as busy on the small screen as he
was on the silver. I've mentioned his work on Batman, of
course (he also played The Penguin in the 1966 feature film…and a hilarious
episode of The Monkees, “Monkees Blow Their Minds”), but fans
of The Twilight Zone remember that Meredith made four
appearances on that dramatic anthology (he's tied with Jack Klugman) including
the classic "Time Enough at Last" (a bookworm survives a nuclear
holocaust). Burgess guest-starred on such classic shows as Ben Casey, Burke’s
Law, Naked City, Rawhide, The
Virginian, and The Wild Wild West. But he also had
regular roles on the likes of Mr. Novak, Search,
and Gloria while narrating the likes of The
Big Story and Korg: 70,000 B.C.
While his role in Rocky (1976) earned him an Academy Award nod for Best Supporting Actor, it was actually Burgess Meredith’s second nomination—he was singled out a year earlier for the same trophy (though he did not win) for his turn in The Day of the Locust. Meredith had to take satisfaction knowing that the sting of the blacklist had received a soothing balm in the form of an Emmy Award for his portrayal of lawyer Joseph Welch in the 1977 TV movie Tail Gunner Joe, which dramatized the life of Senator Joseph McCarthy. Among the movies that Burgess appeared in during the latter part of his career: There Was a Crooked Man... (1970), Burnt Offerings (1976), Foul Play (1978), Clash of the Titans (1981), Twilight Zone: The Movie (1983; as narrator), and State of Grace (1990). Before his passing in 1997 at the age of 89, Meredith was stealing scenes from Jack Lemmon and Walter Matthau in Grumpy Old Men (1993) and Grumpier Old Men (1995), convulsing a new generation of audiences.
To celebrate Burgess Meredith’s birthday, we invite you to check out his radio work on two of our collections here at Radio Spirits. On Arch Oboler’s Plays, Burgess can be heard in the June 14, 1945 broadcast of “Mr. Pyle.” On The Bob Bailey Collection, you’ll hear today’s birthday boy on a broadcast of The Cavalcade of America from March 19, 1945 (“Sign Here, Please”). Happy Birthday, Burgess!